Indisputable Proof

Much of what has been presented in this manuscript is common knowledge to not only geo-physicists but to the lay person that view televisions excellent educational channels such as the National Geographic and Discovery channels. In many cases, there are more than one theory (or even many) such as the origin and details of the Moon becoming part of Earth's system around the Sun. In these cases, we have presented what we believe to be the most probable scenarios and present them as "probable." There are many proxies with respect to Earth's past climate, present status and supportive evidence for Earth's climate future. We have relied heavily on the ice core data because we believe they provide the most accurate and consistent for our past climate. As we pointed out, the ice core data for CO2 are technically not proxy data (i.e. representative agent for CO2) but, as shown in the Figure 55, tiny bubbles provides direct samples of CO2 from the ancient past. There are three primary sources of ice core uncertainties, timescale, diffusion, and sampling. Altogether, these are estimated to be resolvable to within 3% standard deviation (Steig 2005). We are re-assured by NOAA's extensive support of the many American and world-wide groups engaged in ice core data collection, analysis and journal support for publication. Our work is as a result of work by others such as Siegenthaler et al (2005), Petit et al (1999), Siddall et al (2003), Soon et al (2007), Pagani et al (2005, 2006), Indermuhle et al (2000), Dahl-Jensen et al (2012) and many, many more. With complete confidence in the Antarctica, Greenland, deep ocean and other data, we show indisputable evidence that airborne carbon dioxide concentrations has not in the past, does not now dominate our Global Climate and in particular does not dominate Global Surface Air Temperature. Further, that all periods of the Glacial-to-Interglacial- back to-Glacial global climate behavior is dominated by extraterrestrial forces, and indisputably the current Holocene and past Interglacial Periods. In Figures 44 and 45, we show that most probably the three astronomical forces, even in the interglacial periods vary significantly and are far from being understood. Thus, we must accept that we do not understand the mechanisms of our past, present and future Global Climate. But this work does prove that the astronomical forces dominate our global climate and carbon dioxide plays only a small secondary role.